Sales compensation strategy
that pays for the revenue you need this year.
We design sales compensation plans that start from the business goals and work back to the rep's math. That covers measures, pay mix, quotas, accelerators, crediting and payment triggers, modeled against your own deal history before anyone signs. Then we write each plan so your ICM system can run it.
Why effective sales compensation plans stop working.
Sales reps do what the plan pays for, including the wrong behaviors. When results disappoint, the cause is usually a rule in the plan, not the people working under it.
Measures copied from last year
Most comp plans are last year's plan with new numbers. Meanwhile the company moved from new logo acquisition to expansion, or from one product to three, and the plan still pays one flat commission rate on all sales revenue. Reps follow the money. When business priorities move, the plan has to move with them, and it rarely does on its own. The sales strategy on the board slides and the behavior in the pipeline drift further apart every month.
Incentive plans with too many measures
Every function wants its priority on the plan. Five measures at 10 to 30% of target variable each looks balanced on paper. In practice a rep can't tell which one the next hour should go to, and the small ones change nothing. We keep each plan to three measures or fewer, and the primary measure carries at least half of variable pay.
Quotas that ignore the territory
Equal quotas look fair until you compare the territories behind them. One rep inherits a patch of large existing customers with repeat business. Another starts from cold accounts. When the sales quota ignores territory opportunity, attainment tracks the patch instead of the rep, and top performers leave for a plan that pays them for their own work. Job satisfaction drops for everyone stuck in the weak patches.
Sales accelerators nobody reaches
An accelerator that starts at 120% of quota sits out of reach for most of the team, so it steers nobody. A cap does worse. It tells a rep at the ceiling that the next deal pays nothing, and that deal waits for next period. We set each tier against your real attainment distribution, and we use decelerators or per-deal limits when finance needs cost control.
Payment triggers picked by habit
Paying on booking rewards close speed. Paying on cash receipt rewards credit quality and payment terms. Either can be right, but the choice tells reps what to care about, and most companies inherit theirs. On long sales cycles with milestone billing, the trigger decides whether a rep sees commission in the same quarter as the work, or two quarters later.
A design the ICM system can't run
A plan that reads well in a slide deck can still be expensive to administer. Retroactive tier resets, discretionary splits and exceptions agreed in email all turn into manual adjustments every period. We design with administration in mind. We also implement and run incentive compensation management systems, so we know what each exception costs to administer every month.
How we approach compensation design.
Six steps from the revenue plan to a signed plan document. Each one produces something your leadership team can review and challenge.
Start from the business goals
We begin with the revenue plan, not the old comp plan. Which motions does the company need this year: new logos, expansion, renewals or a new product? Which sales roles own each one, and where do roles share credit? We interview sales leadership, finance and sales operations, and write the answers down before anyone discusses a rate.
Audit the current plan
We rebuild last year's payouts from deal data and compare them to business performance. Who earned what, at what attainment, on which deals? Where did the company pay full commission for revenue it didn't want, such as heavy discounts or one-year terms that cut long term customer value? The audit shows which parts of the plan work and which ones need to change.
Set base salary, pay mix and on target earnings
For each role we set base salary, target variable pay and on target earnings, and check pay levels for market competitiveness in your segment. Pay mix follows how much the rep controls the outcome. A new-business AE near 50/50 and a CSM near 80/20 are common starting points, and the role decides where yours lands.
Choose measures and mechanics
We pick up to three performance metrics per role, such as new ARR, expansion or customer retention, and set a specific sales target for each. Then we set weights, thresholds, commission rates, accelerator tiers, crediting rules, clawback windows and the payment trigger. The sales manager compensation plan should pay mostly on team performance. Each mechanic gets a one-line reason a rep can repeat.
Model the plan before launch
We run the proposed plan against your actual deals at several attainment levels, from well below quota to well above it. We check total cost of sales, what top performers earn, how many sales reps reach each tier and which edge cases break the rules. Finance sees the commission expense range next to the revenue generated in each scenario, before the plan year starts.
Document and hand over
You get a plan document, a rep-facing summary and a written specification an administrator can configure. If the plan is going into an ICM system, our ICM plan changes work covers the build. After launch, ICM managed services can run the plan and regularly review how it performs.
What an effective sales compensation engagement delivers.
A plan your reps can explain in a few minutes and your finance team can forecast.
What you get
A written compensation strategy tied to this year's business goals
Pay mix, on target earnings and pay levels for each sales role
Measures, weights, rates, accelerators and crediting rules for each plan
Cost models at several attainment levels, run on your own deal data
A plan document, a rep summary and a configuration specification
A rollout and communication plan for sales leaders and managers
Who it is for
CROs redesigning comp plans ahead of a new fiscal year
Companies adding a role, product or segment the current plan doesn't cover
Finance leaders whose commission expense grows faster than revenue
RevOps teams buried in disputes about crediting and splits
Founders handing initial sales over to a first sales team
Teams about to implement ICM software who want the plan settled first
Related services and reading.
Strategy decides what the plan pays for. These pages cover the work around it.
Sales compensation consulting
Strategy is one part of our sales compensation consulting practice, next to implementation and ongoing administration.
Quotas and territories
A plan is only as fair as the quota and the territory behind it.
Plan design basics
Background on the parts of a plan this work decides.
Sales compensation strategy questions.
What is a sales compensation strategy?
It's the set of decisions behind every comp plan: which roles carry variable pay, what each role is paid for, how much of on target earnings is at risk, and how pay levels compare to the market. A well designed plan follows from those decisions. Writing the strategy down each year keeps plan design from drifting toward whatever the last exception was.
What is an example of a compensation strategy?
Take a company planning market expansion into enterprise accounts. It might keep AEs on a new-business plan, move account managers to 60/40 with net revenue retention as the primary measure, and give both roles credit on expansion deals in the first year. That's the strategy. The rates, tiers and triggers in each plan come after it.
Why are sales compensation plans important?
The plan is the clearest instruction a company gives its sales reps about where to spend their time. Financial incentives change what people do before the outcome, so the plan steers effort toward whatever it pays for. Most advice on how to motivate sales reps starts with the commission rate. We start with what the plan pays for. A strong sales compensation plan points sales efforts at the company's goals.
How do you design a sales compensation plan?
Start from the business goals and the roles that deliver them. Set pay mix and on target earnings for each role, then pick up to three measures. Set rates, accelerators, crediting and payment triggers, model the plan on real deals, and write it so reps can explain it. Our post on sales compensation plan design covers each step.
What is a 70/30 compensation plan?
A 70/30 plan pays 70% of on target earnings as base salary and 30% as target variable pay. It suits roles where the rep influences the outcome but doesn't control it alone, such as account managers on renewal-heavy books and some sales engineers. New-business AEs usually run closer to 50/50, because they own the deal from first call to signature.
What are the different types of sales compensation plans?
The common types are salary only, commission only, base plus commission, base plus bonus, tiered commission and draw against commission. Most B2B sales teams use base plus commission with accelerators above quota. Commission only plans are rare outside independent agents. These compensation structures differ in how much of total pay is at risk, and the right one depends on how much of the outcome the rep controls.
How do you split base salary and variable pay?
Start with how much of the outcome the rep controls. The fixed base salary pays for the role and for the time a long sale takes. Variable pay pays for results the rep can move. Then we check total on target earnings against the market for the sales jobs you're hiring for, so you can attract top sales talent without overpaying.
When does a salary only compensation plan make sense?
When the role has no revenue measure the person can move directly, or when the sale is so long and team-based that individual credit would be arbitrary. Some pre-sales and enablement roles fit. For sales representatives who own revenue, salary only removes the link between the work and the pay, and you lose the plan's ability to steer.
How often should we change our comp plans?
Once a year, at the start of the plan year. A mid-year review is fine, but it should change nothing unless something is broken. Mid-year changes cost trust, because sales team members made decisions under the old rules. If a change can't wait, make it effective-dated, explain why, and give reps notice before it applies.
What makes an effective compensation plan?
A rep can explain it to a peer in a few minutes and work out what the next deal pays without a spreadsheet. It has three measures or fewer, pays soon after the work, and puts accelerators where most of the team can reach them. And it pays for the revenue the business needs this year, not last year.
How do you check market competitiveness?
We use industry benchmarks for on target earnings, pay mix and quota-to-OTE ratios. Benchmarks tell you whether pay levels are high enough to remain competitive for sales talent in your segment. They don't tell you what your plan should pay for. That comes from your sales strategy and your own deal data.
Can a new comp plan fix low quota attainment?
Sometimes. If quotas ignore territory opportunity, or accelerators sit out of reach, the plan is part of the cause and a redesign helps. If the problem is pipeline, hiring or ramp time, a new plan moves the cost around without moving the result. The audit step tells you which situation you're in.
Should we use SPIFs?
A sales performance incentive fund works for a short, specific push, such as the first quarter of a new product. Run it for a few weeks, on top of the plan, and say exactly what it pays for. Pay those incentive payments soon after the behavior. If the same SPIF runs every quarter, it's patching a gap in the base plan, and the fix belongs in the plan.
How does strategy differ from plan design?
Strategy decides what the company pays for and how pay compares to the market. Plan design turns those decisions into rules for each role: measures, rates, tiers, splits and triggers. We do both in one engagement, because the rules only make sense next to the reasons for them.
Will the plan work in our ICM software?
Yes, because we design it with the system in mind. Our team has over a decade of experience with ICM implementations on 13 platforms, so every plan comes with a specification an administrator can configure. If you need it built, our ICM implementation services cover that.
How long does a plan redesign take?
It depends on scope. One role with clean deal data can be done in a few weeks. Several roles, a new pay mix and quota changes take longer, mostly because leadership needs time to agree on the trade-offs. Start early enough that reps see the final plan before the plan year begins.
Tell us what your plan has to pay for.
We will tell you what it takes.
Bring the current plan document, last year's payouts and next year's revenue plan. We will show you where the plan and the strategy disagree.
Start a conversation